Signed from Crystal Palace, Andy Cyrus spent a single season with Exeter City before moving back to the London area to play for Dulwich Hamlet and a number of other clubs. 

Andy came through the Crystal Palace youth system and, after joining the club as a trainee in 1993, remained at Selhurst Park for four years during which time he made a solitary first-team league appearance. 

Released by Palace, Andy joined Exeter City in July 1997 and made his debut against  Hartlepool United on the opening day of the 1997/98 season. Featuring mainly during the first half of the season, Andy gradually faded from the scene and only managed to make 17 league starts - and 25 competitive appearances overall - during his only season with the club. His final game was against Hull City in mid-March 1998.   

Andy linked-up with Dulwich Hamlet at the start of the following season and later played for Hampton & Richmond, St Leonard's Stamcroft and Carshalton Athletic.