Exeter City 3 Bradford City 0- Emirates FA Cup Round One Replay

Matt Jay scored twice and Nigel Atangana also netted in Extra Time to see off ten-man Bradford City under the St James Park lights.

After a goalless 90 minutes, Jay rocketed in an 100^th minute opener and Atangana stole in at the near post four minutes later. In the second half of extra time, the Captain added his second to seal passage to play Cambridge United in the Second Round.

Bradford’s extra time frustration was added further as Lee Angol was shown a second yellow, to condemn Derek Adams’ side to defeat. There were four changes for City for the Cup with a switch to a back four. Josh Coley and Owura Edwards had their chance to impress under the lights- as the Grecians kicked toward the Big Bank in the first half. The strong Bradford side started livelier. Charles Vernam, who impressed in the first game, hit a half volley into the travelling fans. Sam Nombe could have put City ahead in the tenth minute. The number 10 shrugged off his marker and drove into the box. A pull back was seemingly the better option, and the Bantams were able to divert for a wasted corner. Owura Edwards was unlucky not to have opened his account for Exeter. Nombe raced onto a delightful ball through from Archie Collins and sent the ball across the box for Edwards to tap in. The celebrations were cut short however, as the assistant’s flag was brandished.

Vernam went for goal after quarter of an hour, but Cam Dawson was in no trouble getting down to claim. In a first half where ideas seemed hard to come by, Archie Collins side-footed from the edge of the box, just for the ball to loop up and over. 

Elliot Watt almost found a bit of magic with a free-kick from about 30 yards out. His right-footed effort swung narrowly wide of Dawson’s goal.

Edwards look the likeliest for Exeter to open the scoring before the break. Coley’s deep ball evaded all the Bantams’ defenders. Owura lurked at the far post but his diving header was saved by Richard O’Donnell. The first opportunity of the second half came for the visitors. Levi Sutton burst through one-on-one after being sent through by Theo Robinson. For all the world it looked like the Bantams would take the lead but Cam Dawson was the man-on-hand to keep the scores level, with a low save to his right. Bradford skimmed another one wide of the mark as Derek Adams’ side looked promising. The visitors had a half-hearted shout for a penalty as Levi Sutton went down in the area, though Sweeney’s strong challenge was fair and the ball was won.

Handbags were on show midway through the second half as Lee Angol reacted to fouling Alex Hartridge himself. After a melee that Wrestlemania will be proud of, as both players and Colin Daniel came out with names in the book. Colin Daniel almost blasted City in front. The game had gotten a little scrappy but City kept the ball alive on the edge of the box. Tim Dieng rolled the ball to Daniel whose piledriver was over the upright. That would be his last action and his replacement Jake Caprice had a similar effort but with far less conviction. Nigel Atangana, introduced a minute before time, had a strike at goal but only tested the ducking abilities of the Bradford fans. The Bantams almost stole it at the death of injury time. Angol snuck through but Dawson palmed it away. Bradford retrieved the loose ball and laid the ball toward Elliot Watt. In full momentum Watt’s electric effort crashed off the crossbar and the game could only drift into extra time. The atmosphere was beginning to rise around SJP as both teams began to feel the passion of the FA Cup. Exeter used the booming Big Bank to their advantage and through Matt Jay found themselves in front, cueing euphoria. Harry Kite’s fair aggression in midfield won two fifty-fifty challenges and set away the captain. In a two-on-one counter-attack, with Jevani Brown for company, Jay went for goal and took the roof off the net and stadium in tandem! And the passage was all but sealed by Nigel Atangana just a minute later. City with the momentum played the ball wide to Jake Caprice. A drilled ball into the box was met by the Frenchman and jubilation ensued around EX4. Things went from bad to worse for Derek Adams’ side. Lee Angol who had been precariously hovering on a yellow card for some time clattered into Harry Kite and was given his marching orders. In the second half of extra time, MJ showed his class and quality as he poked home a third. The impact subs Brown and Jay combined again via a gorgeous backheel and the skipped slid home another. He almost grabbed his hat trick from the next attack as City began to finally enjoy themselves. The post on this occasion was the only thing between Jay and his third.   

The Grecians saw out the victory and will travel to the Abbey Stadium to play Cambridge United in the Second Round.

Exeter City: Dawson, Daniel (Caprice 78’), Hartridge, Ray, Sweeney, Dieng (Jay 89’), Kite, Collins (Atangana 89’), Owura (Sparkes 58’), Coley (Brown 77’), Nombe (Key 91’)

Subs: Brown, Stubbs, Grounds

Bradford City: O’Donnell, Threlkeld, O’Connor (Kelleher 107’), Canavan, Songo’o, Gillead (Eisa 91’) Foulds, Vernam (Cooke 64’), Watt, Robinson (Angol 64’), Sutton (Evans 89’)

Subs: Hornby, Lavery

Referee: Sam Allison

Attendance: 3,509 (76 away)

By Jed Penberthy 

From the BBC Sport website:- 

"Exeter and Bradford will replay their FA Cup first-round tie on Tuesday, 30 November after the home side fielded a sixth substitute in the initial tie. The Grecians thought they had reached the second round when they scored three goals in extra time after a goalless 90 minutes. But FA Cup rules state teams may not make more than five changes in a tie, including any period of extra time.

Bradford chief executive Ryan Sparks said it was "a disgrace" they had to replay the game. "It's an out-and-out shambles," Sparks told BBC Radio Leeds."The whole situation is an embarrassment to the game and to the FA. "We are the losers in this situation both financially and logistically. They will hide behind the fact that we've been put back into a competition that we might not have been knocked out of in the first place. "At the very least this match should be replayed at Valley Parade."

The Guardian reported 

After Exeter were found to have used six substitutes in Tuesday night’s FA Cup first-round replay victory, their tie with Bradford City is to be replayed. Exeter were within competition rules in making five changes during 90 minutes but then brought on Josh Key for Sam Nombe at the start of extra time. They went on to win the game 3-0, with two goals from Matt Jay either side of an effort from Nigel Atangana.

A Football Association investigation was conducted and the governing body has now ruled the replay must be held again. The rescheduled game will take place at St James Park on Tuesday 30 November, with the winner facing Cambridge United in the second round four days later.

An FA statement read: “An extraordinary incident report was submitted by the match referee which stated that Exeter City had used a sixth substitute during their FA Cup first round replay against Bradford City on 16 November. 

"After considering all of its options, and taking into account all of the relevant factors, the Professional Game Board (PGB) agreed that the result of the match should not stand. The PGB deemed that the most appropriate action would be for the match to be replayed in its entirety.”