Andy Tibbenham was with Exeter City during 1990/91 having signed from Denaby United at the same time as Jon Brown who went on to play in over 150 league games for the club. 

Andy was signed by Terry Cooper from Denaby United of the Northern Counties East. He was named as a substitute for the game against Leyton Orient in November 1990.and later appeared for Alfreton Town, Buxton and Stocksbridge Park Steels.