Bates, one of St Sidwell’s earliest players, appeared during the 1901/02 season several years before the club became Exeter City in 1904. 

Having joined the new St Sidwell’s United club, that had been formed largely by a group of 16- and 17-year olds who had attended St Sidwell’s school and lived close to the current St James’ Park, he is only recorded as appearing in the game against Exeter United on 19 April 1902

With records not being complete for that season, he may have played on other occasions before and after that game.