Exeter have reached the play-off on five separate occasions, each time qualifying for the final at Wembley. Losing 4 out of the 5 Wembley finals.

Date	Opponents	Venue	Score	Attendance	Scorers	Round	Notes
2006/07
04/05/2007	Oxford United	Home	0-1	8659	:	SF	Conference
08/05/2007	Oxford United	Away	2-1	10691	Phillips, Stansfield	SF	Won 4-3 on penalties
20/05/2007	Morecambe	Wembley	1-2	40043	Phillips	Final
2007/08
01/05/2008	Torquay United	Home	1-2	8276	Carlisle	SF	Conference
05/05/2008	Torquay United	Away	4-1	6015	Harley, Watson, Logan, Carlisle	SF	Won 5-3 on aggregate
18/05/2008	Cambridge	Wembley	1-0	42511	Edwards (Rob)	Final
2016/17
14/05/2017	Carlisle United	Away	3-3	9708	Grant, Harley, Wheeler	SF	League 2
18/05/2017	Carlisle United	Home	3-2	7450	Watkins 2, Storey	SF
28/05/2017	Blackpool	Wembley	1-2	23380	Wheeler	Final
2017/18
11/05/2018	Lincoln City	Away	0-0	9605	:	SF	League 2
17/05/2018	Lincoln City	Home	3-1	5645	Stockley, Boateng, Harley	SF
28/05/2018	Coventry City	Wembley	1-3	50196	Edwards	Final
2019/20
18/06/2020	Colchester	Away	0-1	0	:	SF	Behind Closed Doors
22/06/2020	Colchester	Home	3-1	0	Martin, Richardson, Bowman		Behind Closed Doors
29/06/2020	Northampton	Wembley	0-4	0	:		Behind Closed Doors

Paul Farley